Report card comments for reading and writing: 240 examples by grade and skill, and a free comment builder
"Maya is a good reader" is the comment families read most often and learn least from. This guide gives you reading, writing and speaking comments for grades K–2, 3–5 and 6–8, split by skill (phonics, reading aloud, comprehension, reading between the lines, spelling, sentences, paragraphs, ideas, editing and more). Each skill has two strengths, two on-track lines, a next step and a home tip. There are also 22 rewrites of phrases to avoid, six complete comments, and a free builder that writes and checks each one.
Updated 29 October 2026 · Grades K–8 (ELA), with UK English wording · About an 8-minute read
The short version: name the skill, not the subject or the reading level. Open with one real strength ("reads between the lines, working out how characters feel and why"). Say what's on track, give one next step and how class is working on it ("organizing writing into paragraphs, with planning frames"), and end with one small thing to try at home ("ask her to tell you the plan for a story before she writes it"). Leave out labels like "reluctant reader" or "poor speller", reading-level letters families can't decode, and comparisons with other students. The builder below puts it together for any grade band and checks the wording.
The pattern: skill, next step, home tip
Part
What it does
Example
1. A specific strength
Names the skill, so "good reader" means something
"Amara reads between the lines, working out how characters feel and why."
2. On track (optional)
Reassures the family about the part that's going fine
"She spells well in spelling tests and is starting to carry that into her writing, which is right on track for this point in the year."
3. Next step and how class helps
One thing to aim for, with the support already in place
"Our next step is organizing writing into paragraphs, each with one main idea, which we're practicing with planning frames."
4. Home tip
One small, concrete activity that isn't a worksheet
"At home, you could ask Amara to tell you the plan for a story before writing it."
5. Close
Keeps the door open
"Please get in touch if you have any questions about Amara's reading and writing."
A moment you noticed beats any stock phrase: "I was impressed when Amara explained why the main character lied, using three clues from the chapter" tells the family you know their child. One per comment is plenty. Reading and writing are often one grade box but two very different skill sets, so it's fine to pick one reading strand and one writing strand.
Reading levels, scores and checks: what to say instead
Reading is where report jargon is worst. A family who reads "Level M", "520L", "DRA 18" or "orange book band" has no idea whether to worry. Unless your school asks you to report the level, describe what the student reads instead, and if you must report it, explain the scale once.
Instead of
Say what it means
Reading at Level J (guided reading)
Reads simple chapter books on her own and is working on reading them with expression.
Lexile 520L
Reads books with short chapters confidently and is starting to try longer ones.
Reading age 6 years 9 months
Reads short, familiar books smoothly and is learning to sound out longer words.
Below benchmark on DIBELS
Is learning to read short words more quickly; we're practicing with daily phonics games. (If this is a real concern, talk to the family before the report goes home.)
US: the Common Core reading standards for grades 1–5 each include reading "with sufficient accuracy and fluency to support comprehension" (RF.1.4 to RF.5.4), so fluency is a fair thing to comment on at every elementary grade. The codes are for you, not the comment: write "reads aloud smoothly and with expression" instead of RF.3.4. States that don't use the Common Core have their own standards, so check yours.
England: most children take the phonics screening check in Year 1: 40 words, in two sections of 20, read aloud to a teacher, some of them made-up words. Children who don't meet the expected standard take it again in Year 2. In Year 6, the key stage 2 tests include reading and a grammar, punctuation and spelling test, while writing is assessed by the teacher. If a comment mentions any of these, say what the result means for the child, not the score.
Reading and writing report card comments by grade and skill
Each skill has two strengths, two on-track lines, a next step with how class is working on it, and a home tip. Pick one or two skills per student; the grade boxes cover the rest. The names are examples, not real students. They're written in US spelling; switch the builder to UK for practise, full stops, tricky words and term.
Strength Maya knows all her letter sounds and blends them quickly to read new words.
Strength Maya sounds out unfamiliar words confidently, including words where two letters make one sound, such as sh and ee.
On track Maya knows most letter sounds and is learning to blend them to read short words.
On track Maya sounds out simple words and is learning the sounds that two letters make together, such as sh, ch and ee.
Next step Our next step is sounding out longer words, using the letter patterns we've been learning, which we're practicing in short daily phonics lessons.
At home At home, you could point to words on signs and packets and sound them out together.
Sight words Reading
Strength Leo reads all his sight words straight away and spells many of them correctly.
Strength Leo recognizes a wide range of sight words instantly, which makes his reading smooth.
On track Leo reads many sight words instantly and is learning new ones each week.
On track Leo recognizes the sight words we've practiced and is starting to spell them.
Next step Our next step is reading and spelling sight words such as said, was and they, which we're practicing with quick games and flashcards.
At home At home, you could play a quick game of spotting sight words in a favorite book.
Reading aloud Reading
Strength Amara reads aloud smoothly and with expression, changing her voice for different characters.
Strength Amara reads familiar books fluently and corrects her own mistakes.
On track Amara reads simple books aloud and is becoming smoother each week.
On track Amara reads familiar books with growing confidence and is starting to correct her own mistakes.
Next step Our next step is reading smoothly rather than word by word, which we're practicing by rereading familiar books.
At home At home, you could take turns reading pages of a favorite book aloud.
Understanding what he reads Reading
Strength Ethan retells stories in order with lots of detail.
Strength Ethan answers questions about a story and explains his answers using the pictures and words.
On track Ethan retells the main events of a story and is learning to include more detail.
On track Ethan answers simple questions about a story and is learning to explain his answers.
Next step Our next step is retelling a story in order, with a beginning, middle and end, which we're practicing with story maps and retelling games.
At home At home, you could ask Ethan to tell you what happened in a story after you read it together.
Vocabulary Reading
Strength Sofia uses interesting new words when speaking and writing.
Strength Sofia asks about new words and remembers them.
On track Sofia is learning new words from her reading and is starting to use them in her writing.
On track Sofia asks about new words and is getting better at working out their meaning.
Next step Our next step is working out the meaning of new words and using them in her own writing, which we're practicing by collecting new words from our class reading.
At home At home, you could talk about interesting words you come across together and try using them in conversation.
Reading habits and choosing books Reading
Strength Noah reads widely and chooses books across different genres.
Strength Noah is enthusiastic about books and shares recommendations with the class.
On track Noah reads regularly and is trying books from new genres.
On track Noah is building a regular reading habit and is starting to choose books with more confidence.
Next step Our next step is reading a little every day and talking about the books we share, which we're practicing with time for independent reading and book recommendations.
At home At home, you could share a bedtime story every day and let Noah choose some of the books.
Handwriting Writing
Strength Grace forms her letters correctly and writes neatly on the line.
Strength Grace writes clearly with well-formed letters and spaces between words.
On track Grace forms most letters correctly and is learning to keep them on the line.
On track Grace is becoming more consistent with letter sizes and spaces between words.
Next step Our next step is forming letters correctly, starting each one in the right place, which we're practicing with short daily handwriting practice.
At home At home, you could write shopping lists or cards together, so Grace can practice letters in a real task.
Spelling Writing
Strength Omar spells many common words correctly and uses his sounds to spell new words.
Strength Omar uses phonics well to spell new words in a way that can be easily read.
On track Omar spells simple words by sounding them out and is learning common spelling patterns.
On track Omar writes words that can be read by sounding them out and is learning to spell sight words.
Next step Our next step is spelling common words correctly, using the sounds we've learned, which we're practicing with daily phonics and spelling games.
At home At home, you could play spelling games such as I spy with sounds.
Sentences and punctuation Writing
Strength Lily writes clear sentences with capital letters and periods.
Strength Lily writes in full sentences and uses joining words such as and, but and because.
On track Lily writes simple sentences and is learning to use capital letters and periods each time.
On track Lily is starting to write more than one sentence and to use joining words such as because.
Next step Our next step is using a capital letter and a period in every sentence, which we're practicing with daily sentence writing.
At home At home, you could ask Lily to write a sentence or two about the day, such as a caption for a photo.
Planning and organizing writing Writing
Strength Kai writes stories with a clear beginning, middle and end.
Strength Kai plans his ideas before writing and puts events in order.
On track Kai puts events in order and is learning to add an ending to his stories.
On track Kai is learning to plan his ideas with pictures before writing.
Next step Our next step is planning a story with a beginning, middle and end, which we're practicing with story maps and picture plans.
At home At home, you could make up stories together at bedtime, with a beginning, middle and end.
Ideas and detail Writing
Strength Zoe writes imaginative stories full of interesting ideas.
Strength Zoe adds describing words to bring her writing to life.
On track Zoe has lots of ideas and is learning to add more detail.
On track Zoe writes about her own experiences and is starting to add describing words.
Next step Our next step is adding describing words to make her writing more interesting, which we're practicing by looking at examples from books we read together.
At home At home, you could talk about the pictures in books together and find describing words.
Speaking and listening Speaking and listening
Strength Sam shares ideas clearly in class discussions and listens carefully to others.
Strength Sam speaks confidently in front of the class and builds on what others say.
On track Sam contributes to discussions and is growing in confidence when speaking to the class.
On track Sam listens well and is learning to build on what others say.
Next step Our next step is sharing his ideas in class discussions and building on what others say, which we're practicing with talk partners and sentence starters.
At home At home, you could talk at mealtimes about the best part of the day, and ask follow-up questions.
Grades 3–5 (UK Years 4–6)
Reading aloud Reading
Strength Maya reads aloud fluently and with expression, pausing at punctuation.
Strength Maya reads longer books smoothly and at a good pace, which helps her follow the story.
On track Maya reads aloud accurately and is working on adding expression.
On track Maya reads at a steady pace and is learning to pause at punctuation.
Next step Our next step is reading aloud with expression and pausing at periods and commas, which we're practicing with paired reading and rereading short passages.
At home At home, you could listen to Maya read aloud for ten minutes and take turns reading pages.
Understanding what he reads Reading
Strength Leo summarizes chapters clearly and picks out the main ideas.
Strength Leo answers questions about a text in detail and backs up his answers with examples from the book.
On track Leo understands the main events in a story and is learning to summarize them in a few sentences.
On track Leo answers questions about a text and is starting to back up answers with examples.
Next step Our next step is summarizing a chapter in a few sentences, which we're practicing with short summaries after each chapter.
At home At home, you could ask Leo to sum up a chapter in three sentences at bedtime.
Reading between the lines Reading
Strength Amara reads between the lines, working out how characters feel and why.
Strength Amara makes thoughtful predictions and explains them with clues from the text.
On track Amara makes sensible predictions and is learning to work out how characters feel.
On track Amara is starting to read between the lines and find clues in the text.
Next step Our next step is working out how characters feel and why, using clues in the text, which we're practicing through class discussion of our shared book.
At home At home, you could ask "how do you think that character feels? What makes you think so?" when reading or watching TV together.
Vocabulary Reading
Strength Ethan uses interesting new words in speaking and writing.
Strength Ethan works out the meaning of new words from the words around them.
On track Ethan is learning new words from his reading and is starting to use them in his writing.
On track Ethan asks about new words and is getting better at working out their meaning.
Next step Our next step is working out the meaning of new words and using them in his own writing, which we're practicing by collecting new words from our class reading.
At home At home, you could talk about interesting words you come across together and try using them in conversation.
Reading habits and choosing books Reading
Strength Sofia reads widely and chooses books across different genres.
Strength Sofia is enthusiastic about books and shares recommendations with the class.
On track Sofia reads regularly and is trying books from new genres.
On track Sofia is building a regular reading habit and is starting to choose books with more confidence.
Next step Our next step is reading for twenty minutes a day and trying a wider range of books, which we're practicing with time for independent reading and book recommendations.
At home At home, you could visit the library together and let Sofia choose books that interest her.
Nonfiction and research Reading
Strength Noah finds information quickly using headings, contents pages and indexes.
Strength Noah reads nonfiction confidently and takes clear notes.
On track Noah uses headings and pictures to find information and is learning to take notes.
On track Noah reads nonfiction and is learning to pick out the key facts.
Next step Our next step is finding key facts in nonfiction and taking short notes, which we're practicing with our topic research projects.
At home At home, you could read a nonfiction book or website together about something Noah is interested in.
Handwriting Writing
Strength Grace writes neatly and clearly, and her handwriting is easy to read.
Strength Grace has clear, consistent handwriting and takes pride in presentation.
On track Grace writes legibly and is learning to keep letters a consistent size.
On track Grace is developing a neater, more consistent handwriting style.
Next step Our next step is keeping her handwriting neat and consistent in longer pieces, which we're practicing with short handwriting warm-ups.
At home At home, you could ask Grace to write a list, card or note for the family now and then.
Spelling Writing
Strength Omar spells accurately, including longer and less common words.
Strength Omar applies spelling patterns and rules confidently in his writing.
On track Omar spells most common words correctly and is learning new spelling patterns each week.
On track Omar spells well in spelling tests and is starting to carry that into his writing.
Next step Our next step is using the spelling patterns we learn each week in his everyday writing, which we're practicing with weekly spelling patterns and practice.
At home At home, you could practice this week's spelling words in a quick game, a few minutes at a time.
Sentences and punctuation Writing
Strength Lily uses a wide range of punctuation accurately, including commas and apostrophes.
Strength Lily writes varied sentences that start in different ways, which makes her writing interesting to read.
On track Lily uses capital letters and periods accurately and is learning to use commas.
On track Lily writes in full sentences and is learning to vary how they start.
Next step Our next step is using commas and apostrophes accurately, which we're practicing with short daily grammar warm-ups.
At home At home, you could write a short note or message together and check the punctuation.
Planning and organizing writing Writing
Strength Kai organizes writing into clear paragraphs with a strong opening and ending.
Strength Kai plans carefully and builds his ideas logically through a piece.
On track Kai plans before writing and is learning to group ideas into paragraphs.
On track Kai writes with a clear beginning and is working on a strong ending.
Next step Our next step is organizing writing into paragraphs, each with one main idea, which we're practicing with planning frames.
At home At home, you could ask Kai to tell you the plan for a story before writing it.
Ideas and detail Writing
Strength Zoe writes imaginative stories with vivid description.
Strength Zoe adds detail and description that bring her writing to life.
On track Zoe has good ideas and is learning to add more detail and description.
On track Zoe is starting to use describing words and is learning to show how characters feel.
Next step Our next step is adding detail and description, showing rather than telling, which we're practicing by looking at examples from books we read together.
At home At home, you could ask Zoe to describe something using all five senses.
Checking and improving writing Writing
Strength Sam rereads his work and makes thoughtful improvements.
Strength Sam checks his writing carefully and corrects his own mistakes.
On track Sam is learning to reread his writing and fix mistakes.
On track Sam makes some corrections and is building a habit of checking his work.
Next step Our next step is rereading his writing to check it makes sense and fixing mistakes, which we're practicing with a simple editing checklist.
At home At home, you could ask Sam to read a piece of writing aloud to you and find one thing to improve.
Opinion and persuasive writing Writing
Strength Isla states a clear opinion and backs it up with good reasons.
Strength Isla writes persuasive pieces that convince the reader with reasons and examples.
On track Isla states an opinion clearly and is learning to give more reasons.
On track Isla gives reasons for her opinion and is learning to add examples.
Next step Our next step is backing up an opinion with reasons and examples, which we're practicing with model texts and planning frames.
At home At home, you could have friendly debates at dinner ("which is the best pet?") and ask for three reasons.
Speaking and listening Speaking and listening
Strength Jack shares ideas clearly in class discussions and listens carefully to others.
Strength Jack speaks confidently in front of the class and builds on what others say.
On track Jack contributes to discussions and is growing in confidence when speaking to the class.
On track Jack listens well and is learning to build on what others say.
Next step Our next step is sharing his ideas in class discussions and building on what others say, which we're practicing with talk partners and sentence starters.
At home At home, you could talk at mealtimes about the best part of the day, and ask follow-up questions.
Grades 6–8 (UK Years 7–9)
Reading aloud Reading
Strength Maya reads aloud confidently and with expression, even with challenging texts.
Strength Maya reads complex texts smoothly and adjusts her pace to suit the text.
On track Maya reads aloud clearly and is building confidence with longer, harder texts.
On track Maya reads accurately and is working on pace and expression with more challenging texts.
Next step Our next step is reading challenging texts aloud with confidence and expression, which we're practicing with paired reading and short performance readings.
At home At home, you could ask Maya to read a short article or recipe aloud now and then.
Understanding what he reads Reading
Strength Leo summarizes complex texts accurately and identifies the central idea.
Strength Leo understands challenging texts and explains how ideas develop across a chapter or article.
On track Leo identifies the main idea of a text and is learning to summarize it concisely.
On track Leo follows the main argument of a text and is building confidence with more challenging reading.
Next step Our next step is summarizing a text in his own words and identifying the central idea, which we're practicing with short written summaries and discussion.
At home At home, you could ask Leo to explain the main point of a news article or video you've both seen.
Reading between the lines Reading
Strength Amara makes insightful inferences and supports them with well-chosen quotations.
Strength Amara reads between the lines and explains what the author is suggesting.
On track Amara makes reasonable inferences and is learning to support them with quotations.
On track Amara is starting to explain what a writer suggests, not only what happens.
Next step Our next step is backing up an inference with a short quotation and an explanation, which we're practicing with sentence frames for explaining evidence.
At home At home, you could talk about a film or show together and ask why a character made a particular choice.
Vocabulary Reading
Strength Ethan uses precise, ambitious vocabulary in discussion and writing.
Strength Ethan works out the meaning of unfamiliar words from context and word parts.
On track Ethan is learning new words from his reading and is starting to use them in his writing.
On track Ethan asks about new words and is getting better at working out their meaning.
Next step Our next step is working out the meaning of new words and using them in his own writing, which we're practicing by collecting new words from our class reading.
At home At home, you could talk about interesting words you come across together and try using them in conversation.
Reading habits and choosing books Reading
Strength Sofia reads widely and chooses books across different genres.
Strength Sofia is enthusiastic about books and shares recommendations with the class.
On track Sofia reads regularly and is trying books from new genres.
On track Sofia is building a regular reading habit and is starting to choose books with more confidence.
Next step Our next step is reading for twenty minutes a day and trying a wider range of books, which we're practicing with time for independent reading and book recommendations.
At home At home, you could visit the library together and let Sofia choose books that interest her.
Nonfiction and research Reading
Strength Noah researches topics independently and judges whether a source is reliable.
Strength Noah reads nonfiction critically and compares information from different sources.
On track Noah finds relevant information and is learning to judge whether a source is reliable.
On track Noah takes notes from nonfiction and is learning to put ideas in his own words.
Next step Our next step is checking whether a source is reliable and putting research in his own words, which we're practicing with short research tasks in class.
At home At home, you could look at a news story together and talk about how you'd check it's true.
Analyzing texts Reading
Strength Grace analyzes how writers use language and structure to create effects.
Strength Grace writes thoughtful responses about theme and character, using evidence from the text.
On track Grace comments on the writer's choices and is learning to explain their effect.
On track Grace identifies themes in a text and is learning to support her ideas with evidence.
Next step Our next step is explaining how a writer's word choices create an effect on the reader, which we're practicing with close reading of short extracts and modeled paragraphs.
At home At home, you could ask Grace what message a book, song or film is trying to get across, and why.
Spelling Writing
Strength Omar spells accurately, even with ambitious vocabulary.
Strength Omar spells accurately and checks unfamiliar words carefully.
On track Omar spells most words correctly and is learning to check tricky ones.
On track Omar spells accurately in most writing and is working on a few commonly confused words.
Next step Our next step is checking spellings carefully when editing, especially commonly confused words, which we're practicing with a personal spelling list.
At home At home, you could help Omar keep a short list of tricky words to check when proofreading.
Sentences and punctuation Writing
Strength Lily controls sentence structure confidently and uses a range of punctuation for effect.
Strength Lily varies sentence length and structure to suit her purpose.
On track Lily punctuates accurately and is learning to vary sentence structure.
On track Lily uses commas and apostrophes correctly and is moving on to semicolons and colons.
Next step Our next step is varying sentence structure and using semicolons and colons accurately, which we're practicing by studying model sentences from our class texts.
At home At home, you could encourage Lily to read her writing aloud to hear where the punctuation should go.
Planning and organizing writing Writing
Strength Kai structures essays clearly, with well-developed paragraphs and smooth transitions.
Strength Kai plans carefully and links ideas logically across a longer piece.
On track Kai organizes ideas into paragraphs and is learning to link them with transitions.
On track Kai plans before writing and is building confidence with longer essays.
Next step Our next step is linking paragraphs with clear transitions in longer essays, which we're practicing with essay planning templates and model essays.
At home At home, you could ask Kai to talk you through the plan for an essay before starting to write.
Ideas and detail Writing
Strength Zoe writes with a strong, individual voice and engaging ideas.
Strength Zoe develops ideas in depth with well-chosen detail.
On track Zoe has thoughtful ideas and is learning to develop them in more depth.
On track Zoe writes clearly and is learning to add detail that keeps the reader interested.
Next step Our next step is developing ideas in depth, with detail that supports her point, which we're practicing by looking at examples from books we read together.
At home At home, you could encourage Zoe to keep a journal or write about a topic that interests her.
Checking and improving writing Writing
Strength Sam revises drafts thoughtfully, improving both ideas and accuracy.
Strength Sam proofreads carefully and acts on feedback to improve each draft.
On track Sam proofreads for errors and is learning to revise ideas as well.
On track Sam acts on feedback and is building a habit of revising drafts.
Next step Our next step is revising drafts to improve ideas and organization, not only correcting errors, which we're practicing with peer feedback and editing checklists.
At home At home, you could ask Sam to read an essay aloud before handing it in and spot one improvement.
Argument writing Writing
Strength Isla builds strong arguments with clear claims and well-chosen evidence.
Strength Isla writes convincing arguments and answers the opposing view.
On track Isla makes a clear claim and is learning to support it with evidence.
On track Isla writes arguments with reasons and is learning to answer the opposing view.
Next step Our next step is supporting claims with evidence and explaining how it proves the point, which we're practicing with debates and model essays.
At home At home, you could discuss a topic in the news together and ask Isla for reasons and evidence.
Speaking and listening Speaking and listening
Strength Jack shares ideas clearly in class discussions and listens carefully to others.
Strength Jack speaks confidently in front of the class and builds on what others say.
On track Jack contributes to discussions and is growing in confidence when speaking to the class.
On track Jack listens well and is learning to build on what others say.
Next step Our next step is sharing his ideas in class discussions and building on what others say, which we're practicing with talk partners and sentence starters.
At home At home, you could talk at mealtimes about the best part of the day, and ask follow-up questions.
22 reading and writing phrases to avoid, rewritten
Most of these say something true in a way that makes ability sound fixed ("not a natural writer"), uses a label the family will remember for years ("reluctant reader"), or hides the meaning behind a code ("Level M", "digraphs"). The rewrite says what the student does and what's helping.
Instead of
Write
Maya is a reluctant reader.
Maya is choosing short graphic novels and reading a little more each week.
Leo is a poor speller.
Leo spells most common words correctly and is learning this week's spelling pattern.
Amara's handwriting is messy.
Amara is working on keeping her letters a consistent size in longer pieces.
Ethan hates writing.
Ethan writes more when the topic is his own choice, and short writing goals are helping.
Sofia is reading at Level M.
Sofia reads short chapter books on her own and is moving on to longer ones.
Noah has a Lexile of 520L.
Noah reads books with short chapters confidently and is starting to try longer ones.
Grace can't blend CVC words.
Grace knows most letter sounds and is learning to blend them to read short words such as cat and ship.
Omar needs to work on his digraphs.
Omar is learning the sounds that two letters make together, such as sh, ch and th.
Lily uses fronted adverbials and expanded noun phrases.
Lily starts sentences in different ways ("Later that day,") and adds detail to describe things ("the old, creaky gate").
Kai is in the bottom reading group.
Kai is reading simple books with growing confidence and is becoming smoother each week.
Zoe is a better reader than most of the class.
Zoe reads longer books smoothly and makes thoughtful predictions using clues from the text.
Sam is not a natural writer.
Sam has good ideas and is learning to add more detail and description.
Isla never reads at home.
At home, ten minutes of reading together at bedtime would really help Isla.
Jack's dyslexia makes spelling hard.
Jack is using his spelling list to check tricky words when he edits. (Talk about any support plan with the family in person.)
Priya's writing is below grade level.
Priya is learning to plan her ideas before writing; we're working on this with planning frames, and I'll share how it's going at conferences.
Ben is an ELL student, so his vocabulary is limited.
Ben is learning new words from our class reading and is starting to use them in his writing.
Ruby always rushes her writing.
Ruby sometimes rushes, so our next step is rereading her writing to check it makes sense.
Maya decodes well but her comprehension is weak.
Maya sounds out new words confidently and is learning to retell the main events of a story in order.
Leo should know his sight words by now.
Leo reads many sight words instantly and is learning new ones each week.
Amara is a bookworm and a joy to have in class.
Amara reads widely and shares book recommendations with the class.
Ethan's guided reading level is J and his DRA is 18.
Ethan reads simple chapter books on his own and is working on reading them with more expression.
Sofia copied parts of her essay from a website.
Don't write it. Talk to the family first and follow your school's policy.
For a student who is well below where they should be in reading, the comment needs more than a next step: the family should hear it from you first, and the comment should say what support is in place. The struggling students guide has that pattern and its own builder.
Six complete reading and writing comments
All six were made with the builder below and left as they came out, so you can see the pattern. In real life you'd add a moment you noticed and the support you're actually giving.
Maya enjoys books and writing and is keen to share ideas in class. Maya sounds out unfamiliar words confidently, including words where two letters make one sound, such as sh and ee. She reads many sight words instantly and is learning new ones each week, which is right on track for this point in the year. Our next step is using a capital letter and a period in every sentence, which we're practicing with daily sentence writing. At home, you could ask Maya to write a sentence or two about the day, such as a caption for a photo. A few minutes a few times a week makes a real difference. Please get in touch if you have any questions about Maya's reading and writing.
Grade 1, confident with phonics, next step capital letters and periods · 669 characters
Amara is a curious reader who asks thoughtful questions about the books we read. I was impressed when Amara explained why the main character lied, using three clues from the chapter. Amara reads between the lines, working out how characters feel and why. She spells well in spelling tests and is starting to carry that into her writing, which is right on track for this point in the year. Our next step is organizing writing into paragraphs, each with one main idea, which we're practicing with planning frames. At home, you could ask Amara to tell you the plan for a story before writing it. A few minutes a few times a week makes a real difference. Thank you for your support at home.
Grade 4, strong at inference, next step paragraphs · 686 characters
Leo has a steady, hard-working approach to reading and writing. Leo shares ideas clearly in class discussions and listens carefully to others. Our next step is reading aloud with expression and pausing at periods and commas, which we're practicing with paired reading and rereading short passages. We're also working on adding detail and description, showing rather than telling. At home, you could listen to Leo read aloud for ten minutes and take turns reading pages. A few minutes a few times a week makes a real difference. Please get in touch if you have any questions about Leo's reading and writing.
Grade 3, hard worker, next steps reading aloud and adding detail · 606 characters
Isla has a lively imagination and brings creative ideas to their writing. Isla writes imaginative stories with vivid description. Our next step is rereading their writing to check it makes sense and fixing mistakes, which we're practising with a simple editing checklist. At home, you could ask Isla to read a piece of writing aloud to you and find one thing to improve. A few minutes a few times a week makes a real difference. Thank you for your support at home.
UK Year 5, imaginative writer, next step editing (they/them) · 464 characters
Ethan approaches reading and writing thoughtfully and takes pride in good work. Ethan writes thoughtful responses about theme and character, using evidence from the text. He writes arguments with reasons and is learning to answer the opposing view, which is right on track for this point in the year. Our next step is checking whether a source is reliable and putting research in his own words, which we're practicing with short research tasks in class. At home, you could look at a news story together and talk about how you'd check it's true. A few minutes a few times a week makes a real difference. Please get in touch if you have any questions about Ethan's reading and writing.
Grade 7, strong at analysis, next step checking sources · 683 characters
It has been great to see Sofia become a more confident reader and writer this year. Sofia is building a regular reading habit and is starting to choose books with more confidence. A good focus for next year is varying sentence structure and using semicolons and colons accurately. Over the summer, you could encourage Sofia to read her writing aloud to hear where the punctuation should go. A few minutes a few times a week makes a real difference. I have enjoyed teaching Sofia this year.
Grade 6, end of year, reading habit and sentence variety · 489 characters
Free reading and writing comment builder
Pick the grade band, then a level for the one to three skills you want to mention: Strength, On track or Next step. Add a moment you noticed if you have one, and press Write comment. If it runs over your character limit, it drops the optional sentences first. Edit the result and check it again, or paste a comment from ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude or a colleague into the box at the bottom. It runs entirely in your browser: nothing you type is sent or stored.
It flags labels ("lazy", "reluctant reader", "struggling writer"), fixed-ability lines ("poor speller", "not a natural writer", "not a reader"), guesses at feelings ("hates writing"), verdicts ("messy", "illegible"), reading levels and scores families can't read (Level M, Lexile, DRA, book bands, reading ages), "can't" and "doesn't know", groups and comparisons ("bottom reading group", "best reader in the class"), diagnosis and support-plan words, EAL/ELL labels, blame about reading at home, jargon (digraphs, decoding, CVC, fronted adverbials, standard codes), stock phrases ("bookworm", "a joy to have in class"), "always" and "never", placeholders, mixed he/she pronouns, US or UK spelling in the wrong country's report, a missing next step or home tip, and curly quotes that some report systems turn into "?". It's a word check: you know the student, it doesn't.
Put this tool on your own website (free)
Copy this code into any web page (WordPress: a "Custom HTML" block). The tool runs in your visitors' browsers; nothing they type is sent to you or to us.
Middle school ELA: essays, independent reading and the student reading it
Name the unit and the skill. "Argument writing: supporting claims with evidence" or "analyzing how the writer builds tension in Holes" tells the family what to ask about at the dinner table.
Write so the student can act on it. From about grade 6, students read their own report cards. "Explaining how each quotation proves your point" is something a 12-year-old can do; "needs to develop analysis" isn't.
Separate the work from the habits. If the grade is mostly down to missing independent reading logs or a late essay, say so, and say what fixes it under your actual late-work policy.
Point to help that exists. A writing center, the school library, office hours, the class page with model essays. Families often don't know they exist.
UK English reports
Switch the builder to UK for practise, full stops, tricky words, non-fiction and "term"; the grade bands show Years 1–3, 4–6 and 7–9. Use your school's own attainment language (many primaries report "working towards", "at" or "greater depth" against the expected standard, but write those words in full rather than WTS, EXS or GDS). The national curriculum's grammar terms (fronted adverbials, expanded noun phrases, subordinate clauses) are for the classroom: on the report, show what the child does with an example ("starts sentences in different ways, such as 'Later that day,'"). If your school uses book bands or a reading scheme, say what the child reads comfortably rather than the colour.
Home tips that families actually use
The most useful reading home tip is still the simplest: a few minutes of reading together most days, with the child choosing some of the books. Every home tip in this guide fits into ordinary life: sounding out words on cereal packets, taking turns reading pages at bedtime, retelling a chapter in three sentences, a dinner-table debate with three reasons, reading an essay aloud to spot one improvement. One tip per comment, tied to the next step, is enough. Avoid tips that sound like homework for the parent ("please complete the reading log nightly"); if the reading log matters, mention it in a note home rather than the report.
Using ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude for the whole class
For a class of 30, an AI assistant can draft every reading and writing comment from short notes, as long as you follow your school's AI policy. Use a code instead of a name and leave out diagnoses, support plans, intervention groups and family details. Then paste in:
Write reading and writing report card comments for the students below (grade 3, US spelling, end of first quarter, up to 700 characters each).
For each one, in this order:
1. One specific strength from my notes, naming the reading or writing skill (not just "good reader" or "good writer").
2. If my notes say ON TRACK for a skill, one sentence saying so.
3. The next step from my notes and how we're practicing it in class.
4. One small home activity tied to that next step, something that fits into everyday life (bedtime reading, cooking, car journeys), not a worksheet.
5. "Please get in touch if you have any questions."
No labels (reluctant reader, poor speller, lazy, messy), no "always" or "never", no comparisons with other students or reading groups, no reading levels or scores, no teacher jargon (decoding, digraphs, CVC, standard codes). Don't use "a joy to have in class", "bookworm", "avid reader" or "journey". Use [Name] and they/them; I'll add names and pronouns.
S1: strength retells stories in detail; on track spelling; next step paragraphs (planning frames)
S2: strength reads aloud with expression; next step adding detail to writing (examples from our class book)
S3: strength great ideas in discussion; next step capital letters and periods every sentence (daily sentence writing)
Then read every comment, check the strength and next step really fit that student, and paste any you're unsure of into the checker above.
Common questions
What should a reading report card comment include?
One specific reading skill the student does well (sounding out longer words, retelling a story in order, finding clues about how a character feels), whether the rest is on track, one next step with how class is working on it, and one small thing to try at home, such as ten minutes of reading together. Name the skill, not the reading level.
What should a writing report card comment include?
The same pattern, with a writing skill: ideas and detail, organising writing into paragraphs, sentences and punctuation, spelling, handwriting or editing. Pick one strength and one next step; a comment that lists every writing skill gives the family nothing to act on.
Should I put a student's reading level in the report card comment?
Usually not on its own. Letters, Lexile numbers, DRA scores and book bands mean little to most families. Say what kind of books the student reads comfortably and what comes next, and if your school reports a level, explain the scale once alongside it.
What words should I avoid in reading and writing report card comments?
Labels such as reluctant reader, poor speller or lazy; fixed-ability lines such as "not a natural writer" or "not a reader"; guesses at feelings such as "hates writing"; verdicts such as messy or illegible; group names and comparisons; teacher jargon such as digraphs, decoding or fronted adverbials; and "always" and "never". Describe what the student does and what helps instead.
Can I use ChatGPT to write reading and writing report card comments?
Yes, within your school's AI policy, if you leave out names, diagnoses, support plans, reading-intervention details and family information. Give it short notes per student with a code instead of a name, ask for the strength, next step and home tip pattern, and read every comment before it goes on a report.
Let your AI draft them from your notes
The free Teacher Skills pack turns ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude into a report-comment assistant that follows the strength, next step, home tip pattern, matches your length, uses placeholders instead of names, and checks every comment for vague or repeated phrases before showing it to you. It also writes parent emails and rubrics. Setup takes about five minutes, with no coding.
Teacher Skills Pro is £12 / $15 / €14, one-off. It adds class newsletters, quizzes, feedback on anonymised work, cover plans and incident write-ups.
Rather have them all in one printable file? The report card comment bank puts 550+ lines (Pre-K to Grade 5, or Nursery to Year 6 in the UK edition), including next steps and kind rewrites, into an editable Word file and a PDF: £4 / $5.